During the past few days, we’ve been working on trying to visualize our organizational patterns on Fan History in order to understand our own patterns, how we conceptualize fandom, to check for organizational consistency, create tools to help users understand our organizational patterns, to identify areas where we lack stub content. This is our second post in this series. This one is about fan fiction archives.
Thus, we’re creating mindmaps like the one below that do that. The purpose isn’t to get a complete tree. (Some of the categories have 10, 50, 200 different sub categories. It isn’t timely.) It is to get enough of one to do the above. The one below is one of these mind maps. It looks at how we conceptualize blogs. Click on it for the link to the full size.
The structure isn’t complete for a lot of fandom specific categories. That’s because for some things, there are over fifty categories. Some of these were chosen as a representative sample. I tried to put at least eight subcategories in those cases.
What strikes me as obvious is the lack of FanFiction.Net appearing in more places. If there is a category for it, which I’m almost certain there is, it wasn’t linked here. That needs to be addressed. Sugar Quill for Harry Potter also deserves its own subcategories. We need subcategories for archives where we have user lists. We’re also short on archives for sports and theater and actors. The actor related archives might have been hidden or minimized because for a while, we didn’t really know how to organize them. We also didn’t get many actor fan fiction related archives when we did our geocities preservation work.
The Adult Fan Fiction archives section isn’t built really well and really lends itself to other questions, like should we be separating out archives with adult content into their own separate hierarchy? And if we should, should we also be labeling articles that the sites, pages, concepts in question may deal with adult concepts? Added to that, AdultFanFiction.Net isn’t included in that category at all so if the category should be there, AdultFanFiction.Net needs to be included. (Unrelated, I would really love to do something like we did for Inuyasha-fiction.net and FanFiction.Net and YuleTide in terms of stories and people articles.)
There are a lot of multifandom fan fiction archives covering different genres and mediums. This includes FanLib, AdultFanFiction.Net, MediaMiner.Org, and FanNation. They are listed in multiple places like Comics fan fiction archives, Movie fan fiction archives, Television fan fiction archives. The problem is that they are listed along side categories like Batman fan fiction archives, Harry Potter fan fiction archives, Charlie’s Angels fan fiction archives, Wonder Woman archives. This, to me, doesn’t feel intuitive but I’m not sure how else to categorize these large massive multifandom sites and make them findable for people looking for fandom specific archives that they represent. Maybe that’s more of an issue for articles, where we include these archives on the article pages? It needs more thinking and some one to implement.
If you have any feedback on this tree, any questions about how it developed, we would love your feedback. Do the organic patterns we’ve developed make sense? Is this construction too artificial? Is it not logical? And if you’re really motivated, we’ve really like that feedback on the relevant talk pages for those categories.